TL;WR
PERFECT - 16
AMAZING - 14, 08, 12, 10, 13, 09
GREAT - 15
GOOD - 11
AVERAGE - 07
BELOW AVERGAGE - 17
But if you want to take a magical journey with me, let's go!
I wouldn't say any year of HHN has truly been BAD. At most, I can say there's been one "Below Average" year and an "Average" (at default) year. I love HHN so much that even a "Good" or "Great" year is considered lower on the list. So that means there will be 4 on the "WORST" list and 7 on the "BEST" list. Let's do this chronologically...
WORST:
2007 - This is almost here by default. At the time, this was an A+ and in many ways, still is. However, the event has grown triple the size since than and gotten better and better in many ways. Just by sheer volume of quantity on top of quality in today's standards, this ranks at the bottom, but was still a very amazing event.
BEST:
2008 - Just want to note that although it wasn't much different from '07, the few improvements really pushed over the edge from what they did the year prior. This was easily my favorite Terror Tram and Bill & Ted, which were a big deal to me back than. The new/updated NOES house was great, plus getting a repeat of what is still literally the best maze I ever gone through, TCM: BIB. F13 was so much fun back than and so old school... in some ways, I hope we get a F13 maze like that again. And NOES while we're at it, too, why not.
BEST:
2009 - Saw and Halloween are still top tier mazes. Considering they remade both of these and they weren't even half as good is telling how high in quality HHN was pushing out back than. MBV was pretty lame, but the Saw Terror Tram was a blast. This also had one of the best scarezones ever, Welcome to Hell. Bill and Ted sucked that year though (I think this was the nerdy Darth Vader kid one).
BEST:
2010 - I was very disappointed with the announcements at first, but was completely blown away by what was delivered. F13 and NOES were actually better than the 07/08 mazes. They were much more scary, visceral, and aggressive. The older ones had charm, these ones had bite. I was disappointed by HOTC; murder ride section was too long, the 3D was just blurry vision and it was missing a certain charm to it. Even the Saw repeat was good, as they added some cool new scenes, yet kept the same intensity and flow - it was an improvement on an already great maze and I feel a lot of people hated it for no reason. "Repeat" was such a bad word back than. Vampyre was freakin' ferocious for a HOH overlay, they were double and triple teaming, chasing, and getting in faces. I think the only thing genuinely BAD this year was the Chucky Tram, but that for me was a huge guilty pleasure, so I didn't mind one bit (and seems like a masterpiece in retrospect compared to the Chucky tram in 2017). Also, King Kong 360 was open and I got to do that for the first time, it was oddly a highlight of my night.
WORST:
2011 - This was my first time being a bit disappointed with the event as a whole. They got rid of Western Street, so a small stretch of scarezone was missing in an area where it desperately still needs it to this day. Scream was presented as one of the main attractions and it was so sadly underwhelming. The SZ and TT Scream stuff had nothing to do with the property or it's mythos, it just had a bunch of Ghostfaces running around for no reason - so for me, to this day, this had the worst TT ever. Alice Cooper and Hostel were good-ish, but not great. Wolfman was freakin' terrible and I had no desire to ever do HOTC again, but here it was, and this was an ACTUAL repeat where literally nothing had changed. The Thing and La Llorona were great though, but the latter improved even more the next year.
BEST:
2012 - This is where the "every even numbered year is great" theory started to come into effect. Although, there was a fair share of bad this year. Universal Monsters Remix... like W...T...F?! Alice Cooper Goes to Hell was very underwhelming. Silent Hill was "meh," and TCM:SITL was good, just nowhere near as good as BIB. The true standouts this year, that make it "HOOOO BOY" amazing were the first year of The Walking Dead maze and Terror Tram and the La Llorona repeat which somehow got 2 times scarier. This had one of the best Bill and Ted shows also.
WORST:
2013 - There was always something bringing down a certain area of the park. TWD's second year was pretty dang good, but the backlot was being brought down by a hulking giant piece of crud known as Black Sabbath -- dear God, WHY? Insidious was fantastic, but Evil Dead was too stale... literally lots of mannequins for no good reason. El Cucuy was a lot of fun, but there was Universal Monsters Remix for a second freakin' time for some ungodly reason. And sadly, Bill and Ted was probably the worst it had ever been... so bad, they cancelled it mid-run and it never came back.
BEST:
2014 - This year was a MAJOR surprise. Even the properties that sounded lame turned out to be GREAT. The scarezones at this point had been lacking for a few years and it also had a cool TWD zone and ofcourse, DARK CHRISTMAS, my all time favorite. AVP... just a legend of a maze, beautiful in every way. TWD wasn't as bad as people said it was -- could've had some more new stuff, sure, but it was still good. Didn't expect much from From Dusk Till Dawn, turned out pretty decent. But alright, Clowns 3D was the worst maze ever at that point in time (little did we know how bad it could get only a year later), but stuff like Dracula Untold, which I expected literally nothing from, was a heart pounding treat. AWIL was great, mostly for those scares you get in the dark right at the end. And Face Off was a genuinely great send off to the HOH, the best overlay they ever did for that attraction.
WORST:
2015 - Now I say "worst" very loosely here because I really enjoyed this year. I loved the final TWD maze, and enjoyed the return of Insidious, AVP and Halloween. However, there's a few major BLIGHTS smack dab in the middle of this event... THIS IS THE END 3D, which is the worst maze in the history of HHN, bar none. Crimson Peak was beautiful to look at, but ultimately a very...very... LAME maze. The Purge Tram was just okay, I expected a bit more.
BEST:
2016 - What's there to say that hasn't been said? Absolutely perfect from top to bottom.
WORST:
2017 - Same for this year, just... yeah.
BEST/WORST:
2018 - TO BE UPDATED!!! YEEEEHAWWWW!!
#3: 2010 - Yeah, I was disappointed with this year. Repeat of Saw, repeat of F13 and NoES, crappy tram, crappy HoH......at least F13 turned out to be good. HoTC is, to this day, is still my favorite 3D house despite it being slightly tainted by the repeat.
All these years later and I still don't understand your stance on this lmao you didn't experience F13 or NOES in 07 or 08, so they weren't repeats to you! And on top of that, the mazes were 100% different in every single way, from character design, sound, make up/costume design, tone, scares, kills -- everything was brand spanking new. It was the lead up to announcements that was the most annoying, as we all expected some great new properties, but the actual execution had me more surprised that I never doubted anything they chose to do ever again, no matter how much I disliked the source material (except for Alice Cooper). And Vampyre was a great HOH, the cast in there rocked.