Just because no one has ever made a darker Superman doesn't mean they can't. Personally, I would rather someone take a risk with changing a character than giving me the same thing. Also, you guys gotta get over that kills someone thing
I get that that is a big deal for you guys, but...
And ok, maybe not thousands of Superman adaptations, but maybe that's why they did this. He was ready for a 2013 refresh. What if they made a gay Spider-Man or a black Human Torch (rumors are, they are), is that a problem, too? Would you guys keep going on and on that Spider-Man loves Mary Jane, not Mark Jane? Or that Johnny Storm is not adopted? These are characters that should be open to flexibility and most importantly catering to the current audience. People like dark superheroes now. I get that you probably want your comic book characters to stay "true" to the original. Problem is, people like me, who don't give a crap about the characters staying "true", also pay money to see these films and since Hollywood is giving me nothing besides comic book reboots every 5 years, at least do me a favor and change the characters a bit.
Check my posts, please. I have
not been repeating that I love the film. In all honestly, I thought it was so-so. I didn't hate it but I thought it was massively long. It was the only comic book based film I liked this year, but what were my choices?
You hit the nail on the head by saying "not everyone has to agree with the representation of the character", that is my point. That's exactly what my post was saying. This darker Superman is a 2013 representation of a stale character. If you don't like it, don't see the movies that have characters that aren't painted with the brush that you prefer. If the majority of the world are like you, this Superman/Batman film will fail and Hollywood might not risk changing iconic characters anymore.
TLDR; Just because the Superman in this series of films doesn't match what you think the character should be really doesn't matter. This is a new, modern version to satisfy new, modern audiences. Hell, I think vampires die in the sun, but that doesn't make Twilight unpopular. Twilight is god-awful, for me, but boy, do a bunch of younger people disagree.