I guess my rankings will be somewhat off from the majority but I enjoyed Depths and Nightingales despite their flaws.
Top 6 are all solid in my book with the top 2 being gems. 7 & 8 are both really good but just off how I feel about the top 6. Klowns if fun but doesn't offer much more than that. Stranger Things is lifeless. It has some beautiful rooms but the house just feels like a boring book report of the show. This is the only one I do not have a desire to go in nightly.
1. Graveyard Games
Stunningly beautiful with some really good scares. Only gripes are a slow start and a lackluster ending.
2. Universal Monsters
I love this house. Each room is packed with sets and scares. Also by my count there are 29 actors which is a lot. This house is packed with so much to take in. Only negative is how one note the creature room is and I wish the mummy portion was longer.
3. Nightingales
I am a sucker for the tight close quarter houses with the two houses that preceded this house here being my favorites of their respective years. The cast has good energy and has a really solid back half (lion though to the ending). I also can respect the design decisions that the nightingales are a less evolved versions that we last saw and do not mind that we stay under the coliseum.
4. Depths
Opening weekend this house had its issues and the monsters are a bit cheesy. Despite that I love the setting and have had nothing but super high energy runs from the casts week 2. They have also added a ceiling scare that was not there opening weekend.
5. Yeti
Opening weekend had bad timing but second weekend the cast has been going very hard for scares. If this stays strong I can see this moving up into the top 3.
6. House of 1000 Corpses
Surprisingly good. First half has a lot of imagery from the movie and they this house turns it up to 11 when you get into the catacombs on your way to Dr. Satan.
7. Us
Great actors and beautiful sets that really take you though the movie. I can understand that if you didn't like the movie or didn't see it the house will be confusing. Have noticed that one cast is noticeable better than the other.
8. Ghostbusters
Beautiful sets and a really fun atmosphere. Some good scares but not enough and the terror dogs really lack motion and they sit idle for way too long. Still a great house that I have a blast going though.
9. KKFOS
House if fun and has some good sets and use of space for a shrek house. To me the movie was nothing more than a crappy fun movie and so there is no special attachment that elevates this for me since there are very little scares. I appreciate this house for the ambition and scale of some of its elements. This house is all but locked into 9 for me.
10. Stranger Things
Enjoy the show (did not care for season 2) but this house just did nothing for me. Like I said above this house isn't bad but it is just boring, which is a worse sin in my book. Face actors are less convincing this year and the season 2 potion is just terrible with so much wasted space on huge empty rooms without scares. The tunnel is a huge waste that should have only been half its length and the demidogs are way to small, have terrible range of motion and you can barely see most of them. I would have liked this house more if it was just the season 3 portion. This house will not move from the bottom spot.
Barring any major changes I see the top 2 battling for first, 3-6 jockeying for position, and Ghostbusters and Us figuring where they want to finish relative to each other.
Overall a very solid year in my book and one that I look forward to returning to frequently.
PS- Marathon of Mayhem is great and would love for them to find a way to make this type of show a staple of the event going forward.