The Shining seems to rank either really high or really low on most people's lists. I think this is possibly due to a split between those who are fans of the movie and those that are not. I guess some big fans of the film may feel like the tone of the movie has been lost in translation and I can definitely understand that point of view. But, for me, they tell the story of the film while also boosting the scare factor a bit to help it fit into a haunted attraction environment. I prefer this take on the film versus had they kept the scares to a minimum and made if feel more like you were visiting a (scary) museum exhibit about the film.
This is my overall favorite house this year. Is it the scariest? Nope. Does it have the best actors at the event? Probably not. Are the Jack prosthetic forehead pieces atrocious? Yep. Does the Nicholson voice-over actor sound anything like Nicholson? Not really. (Speaking of this, does Nicholson own the rights to his character or something? Why couldn't they use the audio straight from the film? Am I wrong? Is that really Nicholson's voice?) Is the finale very repetitive and missing 'something' ? Indeed. Is the queue setup absolutely ridiculous and unnecessary? Yup. So, why does it rank #1 for me?
While not as scary as say Blumhouse, this house still packs a punch. It's fun to be able to interact within the environment of one of my all-time favorite films. Specifically, I want to give credit to a few of the actors. I've got to give a shout-out to the first Wendy (on Cast A, I believe) who looks an awful lot like Shelley Duvall. She has very good timing and portrays her fear perfectly with her wide-eyed look. I appreciate seeing the first Jacks in the lobby, by Dick Halloran's body, dragging their injured leg through the scene. My favorite room in the house is the Gold Room. I really like how they interpreted this part of the movie. Both casts' Lloyds do a good job of pulling you in and distracting you from the coming scares. Other favorite parts: Grady, the Grady twins, the show scene with Jack and Wendy and the door, and the mirrored hallway with the Bear and the 'great party, isn't it?' guest. If it didn't add about 500 steps and 10 minutes to my night, I would visit this house much more often.
As I mentioned in the main review thread, I don't feel like there's one "amazing" house this year, but had the complaints I made up above been 'corrected' (see what I did there?) I think this house would come closest to being that "amazing" house.