I liked this one for what it is, easily the best HoB since the first, maybe ever. I'm a bit surprised the manic horror-comedy with the memorably silly kills didn't translate as well -- I thought a couple shoo-ins were missing -- and they understandably didn't even try to cast a Vince Vaughn look-alike, but the stand-ins for the lead actress seemed close enough. But even more surprised Black Phone, more of a slow-burn psychological thriller, made such a good house. I think the shortened length helps it in this case. But it managed to capture the uneasiness of the movie while delivering an effective "book report" house with some great scares. I doubt a corporate synergy house will ever be a contender for HotY, but this is a solid effort and helps keep the event relevant for younger generations.