Just watched the first two episodes of How I Met Your Father and didn’t laugh once. Is it serviceable? Sure. But in a world of Superstore, American Auto, Abbott Elementary, The Good Place, etc, it’s just a bland reboot for all intents and purposes.
It’s only 2 episodes of course, but the show is basically HIMYM told from Robyn’s perspective and nothing really funny about it to speak of. Barney, along with Marshall and Lily, carried a lot of the comedic work. In this version, there’s just nothing funny about it at all from any characters.
The 29% RT score and 4.8/10 rating says it all.