The more I read your guys thoughts the less I like Star Wars Patch Cloth Land.
I don't want it to be everything, I want it to be one thing but done perfectly. That one thing, whatever it is, that makes me feel I'm in that UNIQUE place. I want to recognize what I've seen in the movie because it's done like the movie. Sure they need to flesh it out with stuff but at least I will be there and not in a theme park, not in Star Wars Land but there on that planet. That is what is so (dare I say it) "magical" at the Potter area's.
Hell they even try it at AK with Pandora but no one cares (or at least no one with tast in movies).
But it won't, it will be patchwork land and the only question that should be on our minds is; Will the Millennium Falcon in the artwork below shoot lazers or breath fire?