I agree with everything about the oversized theming.
Disney (and Universal) have been making their hotels more generic, which is really sad. Both sides of Endless Summer are practically unthemed when compared to a Portofino or Cabana Bay.
I don't really want Disney to end up building "Disney's All Star Holiday Inn." The oversized theming has charm to it and it definitely makes the hotel feel more Disney-centric. Even if it's screaming Disney at you.