I agree that Horror Nights clears enough money that it shouldn’t ever need to repeat properties in back to back years. But my larger frustrations with late stage capitalism aside, I find a couple of repeats don’t materially change how much fun I have at the event.
For how, Horror Nights is still my favorite thing I do every year and I find it’s worth the high price I pay. Your mileage may vary, of course, but at this point I’m not focusing too much on the lineup as a bar for how much fun I’m going to have.