Initial thoughts sans Beetlejuice:
1. Case Files Unearthed: Legendary Truths - Considering the lost potential of the Billie Eilish house, this was a great tradeoff. Every scene looks distinct with a great variety of scares, even if the story doesn't always make sense. The house flows well and feels on the longer side of this year's batch. This will probably be my HOTY depending on second runs.
9/10
2. Universal Monsters: The Bride of Frankenstein LIVES! - A strong house all around. It's one of the grandest houses I've been through, and unlike other large scale houses in the past, Bride doesn't feel short. The house gradually builds momentum and packs in effective scares. Without plexi, this may have been an all-timer.
8.5/10
3. The Wicked Growth: Realm of the Pumpkin - I didn't have a great run as most of the scares were either ahead or behind me, but the two scares I got were some of the best of the night. The set design is beautiful with unique costumes, and the various smells stand out. With a better run, this could be HOTY.
8/10
4. The Haunting of Hill House - The scares in the first half of the house are badly hindered by plexi, but the second half fires on all cylinders. Every scare towards the end hit me, and with nobody in front of me, the house captured the dread of the show perfectly. Wonderful sets as well.
8/10
5. Puppet Theatre: Captive Audience - Dollhouse of the Damned-lite. This house doesn't reinvent anything HHN has done in the past, but there are a couple standout scenes and scares. The sets can be repetitive at time, which is the house's biggest issue. Otherwise, the scareactors get into their roles and make the house worthwhile.
8/10
6. Welcome to SCarey: Horror in the Heartland - A solid house that's hindered by its length and house selection. The Hive, Dead End, Orfanage, and Leave it to Cleaver scenes were excellent with strong scares, but the other four scenes had weak scares and (aside from Bloodengutz) sets. Ending on Havoc was a bad decision and ruins the punch from Cleaver's scares.
7.5/10
7. HHN Icons: Captured - It's fun enough but poorly designed. Half the rooms lack scares, and aside from Storyteller's room, the ones that do are positioned oddly. Removing plexi wouldn't have fixed this issue. I would've preferred Icons to be in the MIB Tent and SCarey in SS24 as the sets here feel too open without utilizing the space granted.
7/10
8. The Texas Chainsaw Massacre - This exceeded my low expectations, I guess. The 2016 house felt more intimate with better scares, but I'll give some leeway to this year's house due to plexi. The cast does a good job at making the best of repetitive scares.
7/10
9. Revenge of the Tooth Fairy - If TCM's scares were repetitive, Tooth Fairy is beating a single scare into the ground. The facade and set design are the only redeeming qualities this house has. Every scene blurs together due to how one note the scares are. It should've just stayed on the drawing board.
6/10
Other comments:
- Roughly half of these houses would have higher scores without plexi. For the vast majority of scenes, plexi takes away the suspense and detracts from the atmosphere of houses.
- House ops weren't too distracting last night.
- The scarezones feel small and repetitive this year.
I'll be going again in a week or two to get through Beetlejuice and the shows. Right now, I'd rank my HHN years as:
25
29
27
26
28
30
24