My top three were Catacombs, Havoc and Hades. I love the cult following "Cats N Combs" developed and had a blast combing stuffed cats on several nights. The Dogs of War stole the cats from my husband on the last night, but they showed up in a boo hole later in the house. It was great to see Jake in Hades one night.
My middle houses are Psychoscareapy (Team B...woo hoo! Scene of the year!), Hallow'd (Team A Frightanic Guy, Storyteller, Body Collector and Team B Director) and Orfanage (loved the giraffe and my pirate who got me every night), with Zombie on the fringes because I had the occasional good run through in there.
Bottom is Legendary Truth because it was so dependent on timing, with very little good scareactor interaction. The chair on Cast B was awesome though.