Spoiler-free takeway after seeing it in IMAX: I thought it was fine. I enjoyed this maybe a little more than Us but Get Out still remains at the top for the best Jordan Peele film. There were some things I enjoyed, including The dynamic between Kiki Palmer and Daniel Kaluuya. Also great to see Steven Yeun in it. I kinda left the film overall confused. I felt like I was watching two completely different movies.
The film played the horror aspects very well. The digestion scene made me feel the claustrophobia and hopelessness and watching that in IMAX really sold that feel. Hearing the screams of terror of those people inside the creature only for it to be suddenly stopped and see all that blood come out was also unnerving. The Gordy incident scene in isolation also had some great horror aspects to it, but therein lies my biggest issue with the movie.
Now it didn't take me until I watched a couple of spoiler reviews for the movie to figure out what Peele was going for between Gordy and the "ship" (Which was the alien itself which I thought was pretty cool). I later understood from those videos that Jupe thought he could tame the animal that was the alien after thinking he could tame Gordy after that massacre. It makes more sense after watching the movie and those reviews, but I walked out of the theater confused like WTH is up with that monkey!? Why did they act like they were building up to something really big with it only to find it kind of irrelevant to the story?
I hear the argument that Gordy was a needed link to show how Jupe could train the creature, but I feel like the movie would've been just fine without the whole Gordy sidestory. In fact, I think this movie would've been better off without the Gordy subplot. I'm sorry, but while I thought the horror elements involving Gordy were well done, the whole Gordy arc should've been its own movie. It made the movie a little "all-over-the-place" and tried to cram two movies into one.
Again, the horror aspects were played well, the character dynamics and personalities were great. I just felt like Peele bit off more than he could chew with the story and probably put more in there than he should have. Everyone else seems to love it so I'm probably in the minority on this one.
Also I saw it at Universal Hollywood CityWalk's IMAX screen which is the best in town. The screen ratio was weird as there would be some shots with full IMAX and 2/3s of the movie with widescreen frame ratio. Kinda bothered me a little bit but oh well.