Dear Evan Hansen currently at a 53% on RT right now and really getting trashed for both the creepy story and the fact that not only is Ben Platt too old to play a high schooler, but in trying to make him look younger, they actually made him look older than he actually is trying to play a young person.
I have a feeling the age thing wouldn't have been all that big of a deal if this movie was cast correctly. You want to cast a 27-year-old Platt as Evan? Fine. But don't cast 18-20 y/os as the other high schoolers. The rest of the cast should've looked like him (think Grease - they clearly weren't high schoolers, but they all looked the same age) and there wouldn't have been an issue.
On Broadway, "Dear Evan Hansen" was a smash hit. On the big screen, it's poised to be a flop.
www.cnbc.com