According to Google trends,
Peacock has paced at a weirdly consistent 70% of HBO Max's popularity when you finish subtracting the amount of users who appear to be searching for Peacock the bird or sports team. That's lower than HBO Max, but not exactly "what is this Peacock thing lol, we don't care about that" levels. And besides, you don't think tech writers love the chance to crap on a mishandled product launch? It's been months since Quibi's release and we're still making fun of it. They have less material with Peacock because it's just...fine. It's alright. They didn't shoot very high and they managed to hit their low target. Blah.
Re: Roku and Amazon: They account for 70% of the
TV streaming set-top box market. That doesn't include Video Game consoles or smart tvs.
In terms of total OTT consumption on TVs, Roku and Amazon account for 26% and 25% respectively. But remember that there's a ton of double counting going on in that chart, plus not everyone watches streaming video on TV.
This chart on Statista is imperfect because it includes
all forms of online video, but it still shows that people are very willing to watch things on their laptops, tablets, mobile phones, etc, and that connected set-top boxes like Roku are only a small part of the total equation.
I don't want to make it sound like a non-issue that HBOM and Peacock aren't on Roku or Amazon, it's a sizeable chunk. But again, it's only a chunk, and I think people overestimate just how big that chunk is (e.g. I'm a college student, I'm not dreaming of getting a smart TV set-top whatever at the moment because those things cost money and we're in a recession, so I'll just watch things on my laptop).
If they watch the videos, they're still getting served ads, which generates revenue for Comcast. If -
as Matt Strauss claims - Comcast's internal numbers are showing that people who are getting it for free are spending a substantial amount of time watching - which again, they've claimed has already happened - then it doesn't matter how they got it, because NBCU is still raking in ad revenue.