I haven't been on Matterhorn in two years, but man....it's just great from what I remember. In terms of theming, scenery, and story...yes, Everest easily trumps Matterhorn. In thrills though, I think Matterhorn trumps Everest. I'm more of a die-hard coaster fan, for me the bigger, faster, and more intense....the better, which is why, although I do enjoy Everest, I wasn't all that impressed with it. I was expecting something way more intense. The reason I say BTMR was more thrilling than Everest is because on BTMR, there are some legit moments where my stomach goes into my mouth, not that many on Everest (except for the backwards portion and MAYBE the first big fall). I compare the two because both are fairly tame, take place outside on, in and around a mountain, and both have beautiful scenery/theming. To me EE and BTMR are like cousins, with BTMR being the bigger of the two. I hope this explains things to those that were offended, and I haven't been on BTMR in several years, so maybe if I get up to MK again and am able to ride it, my opinion will change. Who knows, we'll see.