I feel like, compared to the other 4 hotels, this one might have been a little...
 "creatively rushed" in effort to get more bodies in rooms.    For me, it's kind of lacking that 
je ne sais quoi that makes a good hotel great.    "Reminiscent of a leisurely estate in the heart of the tropics" is a weak direction to me.   And yes, I'm making this judgement by looking at pictures on the internet 
 
Cabana Bay is a tough act to follow in the creative execution department.