It's pretty rare that a Halloween Horror Nights house actually scares me or gets under my skin - if the house can achieve its desired atmosphere and present some great jumps, I'm generally satisfied.
The only houses that have ever genuinely got under my skin that I can think of off the top of my head include Dead Exposure, Hollywood's 2016 Exorcist, Hollywood's 2016 Texas Chainsaw Massacre, The Evil Dead 2013, arguably Dead End and Dracula 2009, maybe the original HAVOC and parts of Catacombs. It's a short list. Graveyard Games probably would've hit my personal list had I seen it.