It seems like the 'totality' of the attraction....preshows plus the ride.....may be strength of the RotR attraction. If the 4 minute ride was isolated from the superb pre show lead ins, the ride on it's own merits may not be as strong. FJ and Gringotts are somewhat similar where it's really the strength of the entire attraction experience......Now, it would be interesting to just weigh the actual 4 minute, or longer, actual ride experiences... FJ, Spidy, FOP, RotR, POC Shanghai, RSR, Indiana Jones etc. ............Just going by what I've read though, since I haven't rode it yet.