I understand everyone has their own opinion, that's why I'm voicing mine. During your top 25 podcast last year I heard your thoughts on why it was #1. The consensus was The Thing is a prelude for house tech to come (AvP, AWiL). While that might be true, I think everyone was so hyped for AvP and remembered how great AWiL was the year prior, that stamp alone gives it #1. It's like giving the first generation Android phone #1 over the Galaxy s6 for nostalgic purposes. The Thing wasn't a terrible house but houses should be judged on consistency. Yes I had a cool run through, everything worked. Most of the time I would miss a puppet or two. The military guys were standing around. The shitty dog hand puppet that was like 5 feet from me. Plus the most of the "puppets" were basically shaking rubber manikins. I respect your opinions, 90% of the list was spot on. It just doesn't seem like a well thought out #1... of. all. time.