Became a first-time SWO/BGT passholder this year and as of now, don't plan on renewing.
SWO closes Kraken/Atlantis 2 hours prior to park close. And when it is open, they're both running with slow operations. That 5% surcharge on dining is absolutely bonkers.
They're also the most expensive theme park to dine in since they want guests to purchase the all-day pass, which leaves passholders behind. Their food festival prices are at ridiculous price levels (same for Universal).
Disney is the cheapest theme park to dine in (outside of table service restaurants). For $15 I can get a great meal at Satu'li Canteen, at SeaWorld I get decent chicken tenders for $18.