Have you been paying attention to the state of media? And, frankly, more creative products have been lost to time than you could ever consume.
I’ve seen Lord of the Rings. I don’t need to see it again. Anything I “miss,” in my only consumption of it, I can live with not knowing I missed it. I value a breadth of experiences. I have no interest in gorging myself on a single snack.
(And the handful of things I DO repeat, are mostly comedies because I like the emotion the invoke with no effort. It’s not because I’m trying to maximize the consumption. That just sounds exhausting.)