I guess it's my time to shine. Light Spoilers ahead.
I had a hard time thinking about this ride when it came to a review. I got off and immediately wanted to ride again which is what matters the most.
The queue is nothing special. The pre-show and boarding procedure is fun and sets the tone of urgency. The disembarking onto the starship and seeing all the Stormtroopers was a true "holy sh!t" moment. All the pics do not do it justice. My wife turned to me and said "This is f'n amazing". I really hope the CMs keep up with the smarmy First Order attitude as it really helps sell the show.
The main "trackless" ride is good. Fun with some thrilling moments and neat special effects. However, the overall experience is fantastic and what sets it apart from the rest. You’re experiencing a Star Wars story in the height of attraction storytelling. Not a lot of rides feature the size and scope of the sets or storytelling that Rise accomplishes.
Now is this groundbreaking? In a way, yes and no. Nothing here is really new. Trackless has been done, simulators have been done, and it's not like pre-show "stories/intros" haven't been done either - but they haven't been done on this scope. When it comes right down to it- the whole is greater than the sum of its parts; which is what makes it a must-do in Orlando.
One thing that bums me out a bit about Galaxy’s Edge, especially with Rise now open, is the minimal representation of the Jedi/Force. You got Savi behind a paywall, and Kylo’s appearance in Rise.