I assure you, I've been on forums longer than you.
I never said this ride doesn't appear to be a true E ticket ride. Something Disney rarely builds in the US anymore.
However, I still stand firm that it isn't groundbreaking. Marni on Magic is saying that. I agree with his opinion that the ride may be greater than the sum of its parts, which I haven't watched. But it isn't using a brand new state of the art 3-D moving points of conversion technology, it's not ridden on the end of robot arms, its' not a roller coaster with a simulator on it. Heck it's not even the most high definition movie theater in the world with moving seats.
It's a simple trackless dark ride with lots of screens, a few AAs, a few practical effects, and an elevator that doesn't move smoothly the entire way. NOthing new, just done with a large budget because Disney is drowning in their own hotel guests, and they finally ponied up the dough for a BIG ride. They are batting .500 on new sweeping scale Star Wars rides, it seems.
We'll see if they can nail it again with MMRR or GotG. I foresee a continued .500 average.