Screamscape is a news and rumor aggregate site. What he shares could be right, or could be wrong - but it's not him doing the digging.
I don't think anyone (maybe other than Goomba, but I think he was laughing at the Screamscape bit) was laughing at ThrillRide's suggestions of "Nothing is known" - but confused at the overall point he was trying to make. I think we all know, even those who have connections, that things can change - and no one is arguing that or saying different. We all should be in the understanding that this thread is for pinging any and all ideas off each other and discuss the merits of the overall point - including disagreements.
But I will say, it probably doesn't help that Thrillride's reputation of posting hasn't been ideal (for lack of a better term).