Anyone got some recommendations on what they DO have?
Going off this page:
Watch Horror Movies Online | Peacock
Cabin Fever - Worthwhile watch of Eli Roth's directorial debut. Lacks in cheer worthy characters but brings the goop and gore in droves.
An American Werewolf in London - The classic that sits on or near the top of the werewolf subgenre. That transformation scene though.
Better Watch Out - Christmas horror with a demented and dark twist that'll have you clenching your nails.
Black Christmas - One of the founding fathers of the slasher genre.
Body Bags - A fun, watchable anthology starring John Carpenter as the host!
The OG Monster Mash Films (Dracula/Creature/Bride of Frank/Mummy, etc) - The Universal classics, need I say more?
The Chucky Series - Everyone's favorite doll killer, the franchise holds up well thanks to always being the vision of its original creator.
Day of the Dead - The George A. Romero classic (don't touch that remake!) that I think is his best work, personally.
Dead Snow 2: Red vs Dead - A fun, bonkers Nazi zombie movie (would recommend watching the original first just to be up to speed).
Deathgasm - A great horror comedy about the dangers of heavy metal!
Ginger Snaps - The classic teenage girl/werewolf tale.
Henry: Portrait of a Serial Killer - Know that loveable tough guy in every James Gunn flick (Yondu, The Savant, etc), see the brutal and dark role that put him on the map!
Hello Mary Lou: Prom Night II - Bonkers sequel to a generic slasher flick that leans into a Freddy Krueger esque villain.
Night of the Living Dead - The Romero that started it all in terms of zombies.
Nightbreed - Weird and mysterious monster flick.
Phantasm series - A wonderfully weird, macabre, nightmare logic ride into the realm of The Tall Man.
Prince of Darkness - An underrated Carpenter gem that is the second of his "Apocalypse Trilogy" that deserves more eyes on it.
Psycho sequels - I think Psycho II is better than the beloved original but hot takes aside the series is worth watching for the continued adventures of Norman.
Sleepaway Camp - A sleazy slasher with one of the most wild endings of all time.
Slither - A great horror comedy from the twisted mind of James Gunn.
Stake Land - A fine indie flick about the vampire apocalypse.
Starry Eyes - A fine indie flick about the dangers of Hollywood stardom.
The Cabin in the Woods - A personal forever favorite horror comedy that dives deep into the inner workings of horror films. MERMANS!
The Exorcist III - A classic gem that more than lives up to the legacy of the original Exorcist.
The Hitcher remake - A nice retelling of the original classic that features Sean Bean as the bad guy and one of the best unheralded leading couples of all time.
The House of the Devil - A great indie gem about the worst babysiting gig ever.
The Innkeepers - A fun indie film about a haunted(?) hotel.
The People Under the Stairs - A wacky as hell Wes Craven 90's film that I adore. Was also one of the first IP houses to be featured at HHN!
I don't know if any of these have up-charges associated but there's a bunch of good stuff here plus more I didn't mention that I would be fine watching for free (hello, Bill Goldberg playing an evil Santa Claus in Satan's Slay!).