I like these better anyway - gives me a chance to spread my wings and go deep down some weird rabbit holes. So bear with me.
WEIRD THEORY #1. In the band Old Man River (it's his name AND the name of his band), his Bass Guitarist is named Liam Flanagan. Liam Flanagan is ALSO the name of an 8-year old boy who tragically died of a flesh-eating bacteria. Could mean Cabin in the Woods. However, given the tragedy of the story, I don't think
@Legacy would use this as a clue. But it was the first connection that popped up in my investigation, so thought I'd mention it - but also condolences to his family.
WEIRD THEORY #2. The band has a song called "La". Could be a clue to "La Llorana".
WEIRDEST THEORY #3. The band has a song called "You're on My Mind ". Searching that phrase, I came across those exact lyrics from the band "Wallows". The song that contains those lyrics is called "1980s Horror Film". According to a fan who attended one of their concerts, the lead singer explained that "the 1980s film discussed in the track is Halloween 4." So, could be a clue for something Halloween. But, it's a big stretch - say if
@Legacy knows the answer is Halloween 5, he would have had to find Wallows and pick out that exact line to backtrack to the song by Old Man River. That's a tough one.
BEST THEORY #4. The band has a song called "Norway". Looked up Norwegian horror films and came across one called Trollhunter, which got excellent reviews and was apparently pretty popular. Looking at the images from the movie, it looks like it could make a pretty awesome house. So, that was going to be my guess based on these breadcrumbs; however, I figured "why not?" and clicked on the name of the Director (
André Øvredal) just on the off chance something connected further. And, low and behold, he was also the director of Scary Stories To Tell In The Dark. And, doing a "reverse mindset", if SSTTITD is the answer, working backwards I could see
@Legacy start with the director, see that he is Norwegian, and search for any songs or movies with "Norway" in the title, which could lead him to Old Man River and the clue image. So, my FINAL and BEST ANSWER is: Scary Stories To Tell In The Dark