I agree on both sides of this debate.
I love IPs. It's what I came to HHN in the first place for in 2007 when I was SO EXCITED to see Jason, Freddy, and Leatherface come to life for the very first time. That first TCM maze is still my number 1 favorite.
I also love the originals. La Llorona, El Cucuy, and Holidayz in Hell are my JAM. This stuff is necessary for evolution and innovation of the event for years to come. La Llorona is in my top 5 of all time.
I don't split hairs and try to say "oh it was at Orlando/a scarezone first, so..." Like...C'MON. Give them some credit!
The only thing I have a bias for is the musician mazes, which have all been fairly bad, in my opinion. That's why I have zero excitement for The Weeknd, but also, I am willing to be proven wrong.
My ideal lineup would be half IP and half originals. This lineup is kinda sorta that.
I love that Universal has grown to utilize its own history. The Universal Monsters should've been a staple from the beginning.
And even Blumhouse, it's basically all of Universal's modern day horror history. It needs to be represented as well. Vol 1 was meh, but I loved Vol 2. I'm willing to give this one a chance, even though I'm not excited about Freaky.
I do wish Universal would expand out and try to grab more IPs that we've missed, but also it's understandable that companies like Warner Bros, Disney, and etc are doing their own thing now or are attempting to.
In a weird way, The Weeknd is the biggest IP this year, but that can go so many ways, especially if it'll be UV light galore (semi-confirmed) like Pandora or This Is The End. And on top of it being musician based, that's already spelling out "bottom of my rank."
I'm waiting to hear about Killer Klownz before having an official opinion on this year. If it's an exact repeat, my enthusiasm leans more towards meh-ness. If it's an all new sequel, I lean toward more interested.
My opinion is this year is missing one big cool IP...er, at least one that 100% fits.
We've had Halloween quite a lot now, I wouldn't classify Freaky or Black Phone as big, Legends Collide I was hoping we'd get Creature from the Black Lagoon, and so it all comes down to Killer Klownz and what they do with it, for me. We've had it once, but that was my favorite of the year, so if they can recapture that magic AND make it a completely brand new maze at the same time? I'd be thrilled.
But that's just level of anticipation. We could have the world's best lineup and if execution sucks, all the debate is for nothing lol. It's great to go in very excited and leave even more excited, but it's almost pointless to debate what should be or shouldn't be until actually finding out the quality of the content.
Either way, with the increased budget, I think we're in for at least a good year. Will it be great? Maybe not. But I don't think it'll be BAD. And after last year, and having no event in 2020, I honestly just need it to be good to be satisfied. Not everything has to be 2016 again.